here

 

John Gerhardt Left: John Gerhardt.

Right: Sophronia Caviness Gerhardt holding Mary Ann Gerhardt.

Both photos taken about 1874 in East Las Vegas, New Mexico.
Sophronia Caviness Gerhardt
  Sophronia Caviness holding Nancy, girl standing is Ellen, and John Gerhardt.  
 
Sophronia Caviness holding Nancy, girl standing is Ellen
and John Gerhardt.